Impact Fee Update

Affordable Housing

San Francisco School Fees Expanded

On January 11, 2021, San Francisco issued the 2021 Impact Fee Schedule. One change of note is the calculation of the San Francisco Unified School District Fee (“School Fee”) as applied to multi-unit residential developments. The change would increase the fee on such developments by increasing the space in the building subject to the fee.

The School Fee applies to new residential developments and additions to existing residential properties of greater than 500 square feet. Although the School Fee is collected upon issuance of the first construction document along with the fees paid to the City and County of San Francisco, the School Fee is subject to its own calculation rules under California Government Code Section 65995(b)(1).

Currently, San Francisco applies the School Fee to “total habitable space,” defined as space in a structure used for living, sleeping, eating or cooking. The calculation excludes bathrooms, toilet compartments, closets, halls, storage or utility space, and similar areas.

Effective February 1, 2021, the assessable space for calculation of the School Fee for any new residential development will include all of the square footage within the perimeter of the structure. Space still excluded from the Fee calculation includes any carport, covered or uncovered walkway, garage, overhang, patio, enclosed patio, detached accessory structure, or similar area.

The change is based on a 2018 appeals court decision that settled the long-contested question of whether school district fees should be assessed on interior common areas. 901 First Street Owner, LLC v. Tustin Unified School District held that interior space outside of individual units, such as interior hallways, storage rooms, mechanical rooms, fitness centers, lounges, and other interior common areas should be included in the fee calculation under the language of Government Code Section 65995(b)(1). Based on this, the School Fee was expanded, which could lead to a significant increase in fees for projects anticipating paying the fee on the square-footage of the units only.

Oakland Eyes Increased Affordable Housing Fees

Oakland is currently undertaking a mandatory five-year review of its impact fee program. The focus of the review for many is impact fees for affordable housing. Currently, affordable housing fees are tiered depending on the type of housing proposed and the location of the property in one of three regions of the city based on the level of demand for development in that region. There is debate about whether the tiered system should be eliminated, as well as whether fees should be increased over the tiers.

Affordable housing advocates believe that fees should already have been increased to fund construction of affordable housing during the last several years of strong development. Developers have expressed concern that higher impact fees could stifle further development.

Officials and advocates are also looking at other aspects of the implementation of affordable housing requirements. Discussion is underway about how affordable housing is best produced, whether through construction of on-site affordable units or through funding construction of affordable units with impact fees. Also under review is the policy of collecting 50% of the affordable housing fee at permit issuance and 50% only after a certificate of occupancy is issued.

We will continue to watch the Oakland impact fee review process as it unfolds in 2021. We will also watch for earlier changes to fees spurred by the current debate.

 

Authored by Reuben, Junius & Rose, LLP Attorney Jody Knight.

The issues discussed in this update are not intended to be legal advice and no attorney-client relationship is established with the recipient.  Readers should consult with legal counsel before relying on any of the information contained herein.  Reuben, Junius & Rose, LLP is a full service real estate law firm.  We specialize in land use, development and entitlement law.  We also provide a wide range of transactional services, including leasing, acquisitions and sales, formation of limited liability companies and other entities, lending/workout assistance, subdivision and condominium work.